Are Harsh Regulations Causing Health Food Stores to Go Out of Business?

Behind the scenes, NHP businesses are under regulatory stress that the consumer is unaware of.  And more regulatory burden is coming.

After 46 years in business, Kardish Health Food Centre is closing its remaining stores in Ottawa.  This is a family run business that has served the Ottawa area since 1979.  More closures are coming.

The natural health community is being smothered by a regulatory burden first imposed by Health Canada in 2004.

We are told we need this ever-stricter regulatory burden to keep us safe.  In reality the regulations are the danger.  There was no risk to justify this regulatory burden.  A risk analysis by Professor Ron Law when the regulations were being imposed revealed that we were 17 times more likely to be killed by lightning than by a natural health product (NHP).  Our risk of being struck by lightning is so small that it is not a concern.  So why are we losing NHPs over an even smaller risk?

Never before has so much money been spent over nothing.  We have likely given Health Canada a billion dollars to regulate NHPs.  And natural health product companies have spent billions more trying to comply with the regulations.  In the U.S. the same products are unregulated.  We have spent billions of dollars to no effect.  Canadian products are not any demonstrably safer than unregulated U.S. products.

The money we have wasted in the name of “safety” has actually made us unsafe.  Canadian companies have had to pass on the costs of complying with the regulatory burden.  This means that the cost of Canadian NHPs is higher than the cost for the same products in the U.S.  We cannot compete.  Many low income Canadians can no longer afford NHPs.  Many Canadians purchase the less expensive U.S. products online.  These online purchases are made without the benefit of advice from trained staff in a store.

Online purchases of less expensive U.S. products are causing local Canadian stores like Kardish to go out of business.   My experience is that stores ensure they have well-trained staff to help us know which NHPs to take, and how we should use them.  If we lose the resource of our local health food stores, we lose this valuable guidance.  This is going to lead to poor health outcomes.

And it is getting worse.  Behind the scenes NHP businesses are under regulatory stress that the consumer is unaware of.  And more regulatory burden is coming.  Health Canada is planning on imposing new fees this year that will result in higher prices and fewer products.

We need to stop this.  We need to turn back the clock to when we were unregulated.  We need to enact the Charter of Health Freedom to ensure our health freedom  (www.charterofhealthfreedom.org).  We need to protect businesses like Kardish that have protected us.

About the Author:
Shawn Buckley, LLB
Byline: Shawn Buckley, LLB, is a lawyer who has been conducting legal advocacy for natural health products (NHPs) for 30 years, and the president and founder of the Natural Health Product Protection Association (NHPPA). Visit https://nhppa.org
Website
Note: All comments are reviewed by our site moderator, new comments do not appear here immediately.

4 comments on “Are Harsh Regulations Causing Health Food Stores to Go Out of Business?”

  1. The comparison to lightning risk is striking, though it left me wanting the underlying risk analysis rather than just the ratio. I also found the point about compliance costs pushing shoppers online especially useful, since it connects regulation directly to the loss of in-store guidance. The planned new Health Canada fees are mentioned but not detailed, so I would have liked more on what they cover and when they take effect.

  2. The detail that struck me most is the risk comparison: being 17 times more likely to be killed by lightning than by a natural health product makes the 2004 regulatory burden hard to justify on safety grounds alone. The point about compliance costs being passed to consumers, pushing shoppers toward cheaper U.S. online purchases and away from trained in-store staff, is a plausible and underdiscussed chain of consequences. I would have liked more concrete data on how many Canadian NHP businesses have closed since 2004, since the Kardish example carries a lot of the argument's weight.

  3. The detail that stands out to me is the risk comparison cited here: being 17 times more likely to be struck by lightning than harmed by a natural health product. That framing makes the compliance costs and the closure of a 46-year-old family business like Kardish feel like a heavy price for a barely measurable risk. I also appreciate the point about losing trained in-store staff when shoppers move to cheaper online purchases, since that guidance is hard to replace. The piece left me wondering how much of the promised new fee burden has actually materialized since it was written.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *